INSTITUTIA: CurteadeApelTARGUMURES

DOSAR 345/102/2022

Analiza detaliata a riscului juridic si istoricul complet al cauzei.

Inregistrare initiala 16.01.2023
Status Curent Recurs
Ultima Modificare 22.06.2023
Sursa Oficiala ECRIS / PORTAL JUST

Parti implicate

M.F.- A.N.A.F-D.G.R.F.P. BUCURESTI Recurent Parat
SINDICATUL NATIONAL FINANTE PUBLICE - SIND. FISC - REPREZENTAN SI MANDATAR AL RECLAMANTILOR MEMBRI DE SINDICAT NICOLAE LIVIU TOADER Intimat Reclamant
AGENTIA NATIONALA DE ADMINISTRARE FISCALA-DIRECTIA GENERALA REGIONALA A FINANTELOR PUBLICE BRASOV Recurent Parat
ANGELESCU MARIANA DORINA Intimat Reclamant
ASTELIAN MIHAELA Intimat Reclamant
BALINT ANDRAS Intimat Reclamant
BERES RAMONA MARIA Intimat Reclamant
BOANDA MIHAELA AUGUSTA Intimat Reclamant
BOCSKAI ISTVAN Intimat Reclamant
BONTEA MONICA IONELA Intimat Reclamant
BORDAS ADRIANA Intimat Reclamant
BOTEZAN LOREDAN ATTILA Intimat Reclamant
BUCUR DANIEL Intimat Reclamant
BUDAI SANDA ANGELA Intimat Reclamant
BUTA DIANA CARMEN Intimat Reclamant
BUZAMAT DANIELA ALINA Intimat Reclamant
BUZILA ANA EMILIA Intimat Reclamant
CALUGAR CLAUDIA ESTERA Intimat Reclamant
CERNAT LUMINITA CRINGUTA Intimat Reclamant
CHINCIUSAN VIORICA Intimat Reclamant
CHIRILA ALINA MARIA Intimat Reclamant
CHIRILA LUMINITA CLAUDIA Intimat Reclamant
CIOBA MARIA Intimat Reclamant
CIOLOCA ELENA Intimat Reclamant
CIURBA MARIA Intimat Reclamant
COCOARA CAMELIA CORNELIA Intimat Reclamant
CONSTANTINESCU CORNELIA Intimat Reclamant
COSTEA OANA RALUCA Intimat Reclamant
COTOI RALUCA ALINA Intimat Reclamant
COTOI SIMINA Intimat Reclamant
COVACI RAMONA CRISTINA Intimat Reclamant
COZMA ELENA Intimat Reclamant
CRACIUN CODRUTA MIRELA Intimat Reclamant
CRET ANISOARA Intimat Reclamant
DAN IOAN VASILE Intimat Reclamant
DANIEL ENIKO Intimat Reclamant
DEMETER DOINA ELISABETA Intimat Reclamant
DEMETER GEORGETA MONIA Intimat Reclamant
DILEAN DIANA MEDA Intimat Reclamant
DOMSA CLAUDIA ELENA Intimat Reclamant
DRAGUT ANDREA NOEMI Intimat Reclamant
POP GEZA Intimat Reclamant
POP IOANA Intimat Reclamant
FARCAS ADRIANA LAURA Intimat Reclamant
POP IONELA OLGUTA Intimat Reclamant
FARCAS RALUCA Intimat Reclamant
FILIP COSMIN Intimat Reclamant
POPA RODICA Intimat Reclamant
FLOARE CORINA MIHAELA Intimat Reclamant
GERMAN MIHAELA Intimat Reclamant
CHIRA DUMITRU ADRIAN Intimat Reclamant
GLIGOR ANGELICA Intimat Reclamant
PORUMB (MOLDOVAN) ANCA OLIMPIA Intimat Reclamant
GLIGOR SIDONIA GABRIELA Intimat Reclamant
HAIDUC ADELA Intimat Reclamant
PORUMB SERGIU STEFAN Intimat Reclamant
HAJDU EMESE Intimat Reclamant
HARSAN ANGELA Intimat Reclamant
PRESECAN CAMELIA Intimat Reclamant
HARSAN CALIN IONEL Intimat Reclamant
HORHAT MONICA Intimat Reclamant
PRICOPIE FLORINA Intimat Reclamant
HURUBA MARIA Intimat Reclamant
PUSCAS ALINA Intimat Reclamant
IFTIMIE SMARANDA DIANA Intimat Reclamant
ILEA MARIA LUCIA Intimat Reclamant
PUSCASU CRINA Intimat Reclamant
ILOVAN ELENA EMILIA Intimat Reclamant
IOSIF VERONICA Intimat Reclamant
RADU EUGENIA IOANA Intimat Reclamant
LASZLO ARPAD Intimat Reclamant
RAT GABRIEL Intimat Reclamant
LUCA NICOLAE Intimat Reclamant
RAUTA BOGDAN Intimat Reclamant
MAIOR ADRIANA ANGELICA Intimat Reclamant
MAN NICOLETA Intimat Reclamant
ROSCA MIHAELA Intimat Reclamant
RUS LUCRETIA Intimat Reclamant
MANDANAC RODICA MARIA Intimat Reclamant
SAND MARIA-MIRELA Intimat Reclamant
MARINCA IOANA BIANCA Intimat Reclamant
MENGHESI GABRIELA MIRELA Intimat Reclamant
SERBANATI AURORA Intimat Reclamant
MINZAR MIHAELA Intimat Reclamant
SIMON ENIKO Intimat Reclamant
MOLDOVAN BIANCA HERMINA Intimat Reclamant
SUBA LORAND Intimat Reclamant
MOLDOVAN CARMEN MARIA Intimat Reclamant
MOLDOVAN DELIA MONICA Intimat Reclamant
MOLDOVAN EMILIA CLAUDIA Intimat Reclamant
SUMANDEA MARTA Intimat Reclamant
MOLNAR VALERIA VOICHITA Intimat Reclamant
MORAR VASILICA Intimat Reclamant
MOSNEAG NICOLETA Intimat Reclamant
SZABO MELINDA RODICA Intimat Reclamant
MURESAN CLAUDIA IONELA Intimat Reclamant
MUS OTILIA CLAUDIA Intimat Reclamant
NEAG DANIELA MARILENA Intimat Reclamant
NEGREA MARCELA VIOLETA Intimat Reclamant
NEGREA TEODORA CRISTINA Intimat Reclamant

Sedinte si Solutii

Data: 16.05.2023
SOLUTIE: cu casare
ADMITE recursurile formulate de DIRECTIA GENERALA REGIONALA A FINANTELOR PUBLICE BRASOV si AGENTIA NATIONALA DE ADMINISTRARE FISCALA prin DIRECTIA GENERALA REGIONALA A FINANTELOR PUBLICE BUCURESTI (cu sediul/domiciliul), impotriva sentintei civile nr. 574/23.09.2022, pronuntata de Tribunalul Mures, in dosarul nr. 345/102/2022.
CASEAZA in parte sentinta de mai sus si in rejudecare dispune:
RESPINGE actiunea formulata si precizata de reclamantul SINDICATUL NATIONAL FINANTE PUBLICE – SINDFISC, cu sediul in , in numele membrilor de sindicat Angelescu Mariana Dorina, Astelian Mihaela, Balint Andras, Beres Ramona Maria, Boanda Mihaela Augusta, Bocskai Istvan, Bontea Monica Ionela, Bordas Adriana, Botezan Loredan Attila, Bucur Daniel, Budai Sanda Angela, Buta Diana Carmen, Buzamat Daniela Alina, Buzila Ana Emilia, Calugar Claudia Estera, Cernat Luminita Cringuta, Chinciusan Viorica, Chirila Alina Maria, Chirila Luminita Claudia, Cioba Maria, Cioloca Elena, Ciurba Maria, Cocoara Camelia Cornelia, Constantinescu Cornelia, Costea Oana Raluca, Cotoi Raluca Alina, Cotoi Simina, Covaci Ramona Cristina, Cozma Elena, Craciun Codruta Mirela, Cret Anisoara, Dan Ioan Vasile, Daniel Eniko, Demeter Doina Elisabeta, Demeter Georgeta Monia, Dilean Diana Meda, Domsa Claudia Elena, Dragut Andrea Noemi, Pop Geza, Pop Ioana, Farcas Adriana Laura, Pop Ionela Olguta, Farcas Raluca, Filip Cosmin, Popa Rodica, Floare Corina Mihaela, German Mihaela, Chira Dumitru Adrian, Gligor Angelica, Porumb (Moldovan) Anca Olimpia, Gligor Sidonia Gabriela, Haiduc Adela, Porumb Sergiu Stefan, Hajdu Emese, Harsan Angela, Presecan Camelia, Harsan Calin Ionel, Horhat Monica, Pricopie Florina, Huruba Maria, Puscas Alina, Iftimie Smaranda Diana, Ilea Maria Lucia, Puscasu Crina, Ilovan Elena Emilia, Iosif Veronica, Radu Eugenia Ioana, Laszlo Arpad, Rat Gabriel, Luca Nicolae, Rauta Bogdan, Maior Adriana Angelica, Man Nicoleta, Rosca Mihaela, Rus Lucretia, Mandanac Rodica Maria, Sand Maria-Mirela, Marinca Ioana Bianca, Menghesi Gabriela Mirela, Serbanati Aurora, Minzar Mihaela, Simon Eniko, Moldovan Bianca Hermina, Suba Lorand, Moldovan Carmen Maria, Moldovan Delia Monica, Moldovan Emilia Claudia, Sumandea Marta, Molnar Valeria Voichita, Morar Vasilica, Mosneag Nicoleta, Szabo Melinda Rodica, Muresan Claudia Ionela, Mus Otilia Claudia, Neag Daniela Marilena, Negrea Marcela Violeta, Negrea Teodora Cristina, Nemes Anuta, Tavasi Paraschiva, Nicola Maria Magdalena, Nicolae Emanuela Maria, Todoran Neli Simona, Nistor Dana Roxana, Oanes Adela Marcela, Toth Cornelia Ana, Oltean Mariana, Tudor Mariana, Oltean Valentina Gabriela, Ungureanu Covasan Alina, Vaida Margit, Oprea Ghizela, Voda Constantin, Orha Elena Maria, Zachiu Gheorghe Cristian, Petrov Andreia Maria, Pilca Viorica, Pintea Cosmina Melania, Pocol Livia Viorica, Pop Alina Aurelia, in contradictoriu cu parata DIRECTIA GENERALA REGIONALA A FINANTELOR PUBLICE BRASOV, cu sediul si respectiv, si cu parata AGENTIA NATIONALA DE ADMINISTRARE FISCALA, cu sediul, relativ la actiunea formulata in numele membrului de sindicat Bontea Monica Ionela.
MENTINE dispozitiile instantei cu privire la respingerea exceptiei prescriptiei si a lipsei calitatii procesuale pasive.
Definitiva.
Pronuntata potrivit art. 402 din codul de procedura civila, prin punerea solutiei la dispozitia partilor prin mijlocirea grefei instantei azi, 16.05.2023.
......................
Cu opinie separata.
Respinge recursurile formulate de DGRFP Brasov si ANAF prin DGRFP Brasov
Data: 19.04.2023
SOLUTIE: Repus pe rol
Repus pe rol, termen de judecata la data de 16 mai 2023.
Data: 14.03.2023
SOLUTIE: Amana cauza
Acorda un nou termen de judecata pentru data de 19.04.2023.
Data: 14.03.2023
SOLUTIE: Incheiere
Incuviinteaza abtinerea doamnei judecator Corina Ioana Muresan de la solutionarea recursului declarat de parata Directia Generala Regionala a Finantelor Publice Brasov, cu sediul in Municipiul Brasov, str. Mihail Kogalniceanu nr. 7, jud. Brasov, impotriva Sentintei civile nr. 574 din 23.09.2022 pronuntata de Tribunalul Mures, Sectia Contencios Administrativ si Fiscal in dosarul nr. 345/102/2022.
Fara cale de atac.
Data in Camera de Consiliu si pronuntata in sedinta publica din 13 martie 2023.

Detalii Tehnice

Obiect Dosar
litigiu privind functionarii publici (Legea Nr.188/1999)
Materia Juridica
Contenciosadministrativsifiscal