Data: 09.10.2023
SOLUTIE: Admitere recurs
Admite recursul formulat de Directia Generala Regionala a Finantelor Publice Brasov (cu sediul ), impotriva sentintei civile nr. 659/20.10.2022, pronuntata de Tribunalul Mures, in dosarul nr. 3029/102/2021.
Admite recursul formulat de Sindicatul Finante Mures (cu sediul ), in numele membrilor de sindicat Szabó Horatiu, Sintean Olivia si Florescu Dan, impotriva aceleiasi sentinte.
Caseaza sentinta de mai sus si dispune:
1. RESPINGE exceptia lipsei calitatii procesuale pasive a paratei Directia Generala Regionala a Finantelor Publice Brasov in privinta actiunii formulate de reclamantul Sindicatul Finante Mures (date de identificare), in numele membrilor de sindicat Szabó Horatiu, Sintean Olivia si Florescu Dan.
Trimite cauza spre rejudecare primei instante cu privire la cererea formulata in numele membrilor de sindicat Szabó Horatiu, Sintean Olivia si Florescu Dan.
2. RESPINGE ca neintemeiata actiunea formulata de reclamantul Sindicatul Finante Mures (cu sediul ), in numele membrilor de sindicat:
Albert Éva (domiciliata in ), Anca Emilia (domiciliata in ), Andrei Luminita-Luana (), Atrejei Dan (), Axente Dan-Lucian domiciliat in , Balea Mariana (domiciliata in ), Banu Adela (domiciliata in ), Balut Daniela (domiciliata in ), Barsan Viorica-Daniela (domiciliata in ), Blaga Daniela (domiciliata in ), Blaj Valeria (domiciliata in ), Boamba Adriana (domiciliata in , Bogdan Anca-Maria (domiciliata in ), Bogdan Cristina (domiciliata in ), Bologa Dana-Camelia (domiciliata in ), Borbat Eugenia (domiciliata in ), Bota Adriana (domiciliata in ), Bratan Adela (domiciliata in ),BucurAnca-Nicoleta (domiciliata in ), Buja Mioara (domiciliata in ), Bult Marcela (domiciliata in ), Burdulea Claudia-Ramona (domiciliata in ), Burlea Victoria (domiciliata in ),Capota Liliana-Niculina (domiciliata in ), Calugar Ana (domiciliata in ), Catana Daniela (domiciliata in ), Ceteras Anca-Gabriela (domiciliata in ), Chereches Ramona-Maria (domiciliata in ), Chertes Simona (domiciliata in ),Chiorean Camelia-Monica (domiciliata in ), Chirila Elena-Iulia (domiciliata in ), Ciobanu Gabriela-Mihaela (domiciliata in ),Ciocan Gavril-Gabriel (domiciliat in ), Ciumas Violeta-Mirela (domiciliata in ), Cimpeanu Carolina Aurelia (domiciliata in ),Codarcea Valentin (domiciliat in ), Coman Minodora (domiciliata in ), Coman Simona-Klara (domiciliata in ), Condrea Ana-Ramona (domiciliata in ), Coroja Alexandrina-Dana (domiciliata in ), Cotta Gabriela (domiciliata in ), Covrig Maria-Elisabeta (domiciliata in Tg ), Crefelean Ioana-Cristina (domiciliata in ), Cristian Maria (domiciliata in ),Cucuta Aurora (domiciliata in ), Dan Maria-Daniela (domiciliata in ), Domokos Ildikó-Gabriella (domiciliata in ), Dragan Maria (domiciliata ), Dragan Vasile-Catalin (domiciliat in ), Dredetean Ana-Cosmina (domiciliata in ), Dula Adriana-Maria (domiciliata in ),Dumbrava Calin-Teodor (domiciliat in ), Farkas Ildikó (domiciliata in ),Faur Laura-Adriana (domiciliata in ), Farcas Ioana-Mirela (domiciliata in ), Feier Cristian-Ioan (domiciliat in ), Festeu Anda-Manuela (domiciliata in ),Filimon Catalina (domiciliata in ), Filpisan Oana-Cristina (domiciliata in ), Flanja Simona (domiciliata in ), Florea Cristian (domiciliat in ), Florea Fironica (domiciliata in ), Florescu Dan (domiciliat in ), Frandes Veronica-Daniela (domiciliata in ),Fratila Tiberiu-Victor-Octavian (domiciliat in ), Galambfalvi Mária (domiciliata in ),Gal-Maties Simona-Mariana (domiciliata in ),Gal-Maties Traian-Ioan (domiciliat in ), Gavrilas Mirela-Bianca (domiciliata in ), Gherman Paula-Maria (domiciliata in ), Ghira Eugen-Liviu (domiciliat in ), Gorcitz Lucica (domiciliata in ), Grama Codruta-Cristina (domiciliata in ), Graur Codruta-Laurentia (domiciliata in ), Groza Maria-Mirabela (domiciliata in ), Hadar Maria-Aurora (domiciliata in ), Hanca Mária-Magdolna (domiciliata in ), Hancu Diana-Alexandrina (domiciliata in ), Hulpus Mihaela (domiciliata in ),Husar Mihaela (domiciliata in ),Huza Simona-Irma (domiciliata in ), Iagar Adela (domiciliata in ), Iftime Smaranda-Diana (domiciliata in ), Igna Delia-Maria (domiciliata in ), Ilovan Ioan-Claudiu (domiciliat in ), Ionescu Codruta-Elena (domiciliata in ), Kacso Ildikó (domiciliata in ), Kaisser Adriana (domiciliata in ), Kaisser Robert-Felix (domiciliat in ), Kakucs Gizella (domiciliata in ), Kerekes Ioan (domiciliat in ), Kovacs Attila (domiciliat in ), Kun Ileana-Olga (domiciliata in ), Lazar Veronica (domiciliata in ), Lacatus Felicia (domiciliata in ), Litiu Ioan (domiciliat in ), Luca Mirela (domiciliata in ), Major Corina-Maria (domiciliata in ), Maksai Dorina (domiciliata in ), Masca Dorin (domiciliat in ), Matei Rodica (domiciliata in ), Mazilu Cristian-Gheorghe (domiciliat in ), Maties Ana-Camelia (domiciliata in ), Mandroiu Roxana-Cristina (domiciliata in ), Mehes Anca (domiciliata in ),Mera Carmen (domiciliata in ), Mihali Mihaela-Camelia (domiciliata in ), Mihaila Anca-Ioana (domiciliata in ), Mihaila Valentin-Ion (domiciliat ), Mihut Anica-Cristina (domiciliata in ), Mirion Cristian (domiciliat in ), Mindru Maria (domiciliata in ), Moldovan Alina (domiciliata in ), Moldovan Alin-Nicolae (domiciliat in ), Moldovan Daniela-Elena (domiciliata in), Moldovan Daniel-Aurel (domiciliat in), Moldovan Elisabeta (domiciliata in ),Moldovan Mirel-Ioan (domiciliat in), Moldovan Oana-Emilia (domiciliata in), Moldovan Simona-Maria (domiciliata in), Moldovan Sorin-Gavril(domiciliat in), Moldovan Teodor-Marius (domiciliat in), Morar Ana-Veronica (domiciliata in), Morariu Codruta (domiciliata in), Moraru Simona-Amalia (domiciliata in), Moscviciov Victoria (domiciliata in), Mosneag Nicoleta (domiciliata in), Murar Vasile (domiciliat in), Muresan Manuela-Sanda (domiciliata in), Muth Adriana (domiciliata in), Naghi Claudiu-Petru (domiciliat), Naghi Sebastian-Alexandru (domiciliat in), Nagy Camelia-Melinda (domiciliata in), Naste Ramona-Maria(domiciliata in), Nasturas Gabriela (domiciliata in), Negrut Florina (domiciliata in), Negruti Elena-Lacramioara (domiciliata in), Nicoara Marinela-Sorina (domiciliata in), Nistor Maria-Raluca (domiciliata in ), Obreja Daniel-Ionel (domiciliat in), Oniciuc Elena (domiciliata in), Oroian Oana-Amalia (domiciliata in), Oroian Silviu-Cosmin(domiciliat in), Pantea Liana-Monica (domiciliata in), Pasca Dumitru-Daniel (domiciliat in), Petrea Claudia (domiciliata in), Petric Gabriela (domiciliata in), Petru Monica (domiciliata in), Pintea Alina-Ana (domiciliata in), Pintea Doina (domiciliata in), Plamadiala Eugenia (domiciliata in), Poenar Veronica (domiciliata in),Pop Camelia-Ramona (domiciliata in), Pop Claudia (domiciliata in), Pop Cristina-Izabella (domiciliata in), Pop Florin (domiciliata in), Pop Ioana (domiciliata in), Pop Leon-Daniel (domiciliata in ), Pop Letitia (domiciliata in), Pop Maria-Daniela (domiciliata in), Pop Marius-Radu (domiciliat in), Pop Vasile (domiciliat in), Potrea Ioan-Gheorghe (domiciliat in), Precup Claudia-Teodora (domiciliata in), Prozan Mihaela-Viorica (domiciliata in), Pui Eugen-Horatiu (domiciliat in), Pungea Luminita-Mariana (domiciliata in ), Rad Ildiko-Maria (domiciliata in), Rad Petruta (domiciliata in), Radovan Laura-Stefania (domiciliata in), Rosca Cora-Adriana (domiciliata in), Rus Vasile-Claudiu (domiciliat in ), Rusu Ana-Maria (domiciliata in), Sala Grigore-Crinisor (domiciliata in), Sacalean Carmen-Aureliana (domiciliata), Salagean Lucia-Dorina (domiciliata in), Sangerean Andreea-Diana (domiciliata in), Sangerean Horatiu-Mircea (domiciliat in), Senatovici Mihaela-Cornelia (domiciliata in), Sfiriac Ramona (domiciliata in), Sfiriac Sebastian-Claudiu (domiciliat in), Sigmirean Anamaria-Dolores (domiciliata in), Sim Anuta (domiciliata in), Simon-Losteiner Ileana (domiciliata in), Sintean Olivia (domiciliata in), Stanca Maria (domiciliata in),Stanciu Irén (domiciliata in),Stoica Cristian-Ioan (domiciliat in), Suciu Camelia (domiciliata in), Suciu Camelia-Ana (domiciliata in), Suciu Ileana-Angela (domiciliata in), Suciu Leonin (domiciliat in), Suciu Petruta-Otilia (domiciliata in), Szabó Horatiu (domiciliat in), Szatmari Angela (domiciliata in), Sandor Ironim-Ioan (domiciliat in ), Serban Maria (domiciliata in), Sosiu Alexandra-Corina (domiciliata in), Stefan Daniela (domiciliata in,), Suica Elena (domiciliata in), Sumalan Judith-Bogárka (domiciliata in), Susca Maria-Ioana (domiciliata in), Suteu Ana-Agneta (domiciliata in), Suteu Maria-Ana (domiciliata in), Suteu Rodica (domiciliata in), Takács Elena-Sabina (domiciliata in), Tamas Ileana (domiciliata in), Tanase Marian (domiciliat in),Tatar Dan-Olimpiu(domiciliat in ), Timar Andrea-Ioana (domiciliata in), Tinca Gabriel-Ilie (domiciliat in ), Tinca Laura-Emilia (domiciliata in),Toma Florina-Adriana (domiciliata in), Toma Letitia-Minerva (domiciliata in), Trif Oana-Maria (domiciliata in), Trif Valer (domiciliat in), Turc Ioana-Lavinia (domiciliata in), Tantareanu Mihai-Ioan (domiciliat in),Tetcu Adriana-Alina (domiciliata in), Ugran Cristian (domiciliat in), Usuc Carmen (domiciliata in), Valesareanu-Mester Ramona-Vasilica (domiciliata in), Vasiliu Elena-Adriana (domiciliata in), Vass Tünde (domiciliata in), Vantu Lucian (domiciliat in), Vlad Ramona-Angela (domiciliata in), Vlasa Gheorghe-Vasile (domiciliat), Vlasiu Marioara (domiciliata in), Vlasceanu Corina (domiciliata in),Voda Carla (domiciliata in), Voda Domnica (domiciliata in), Voda Mihaiela (domiciliata in), Zogorean Florin-Vasile (domiciliat in), - toti cu domiciliul procesual ales, in contradictoriu cu parata Directia Generala Regionala a Finantelor Publice Brasov (cu sediul).
Definitiva.
Pronuntata potrivit art. 396 al. 2 din codul de procedura civila, prin punerea solutiei la dispozitia partilor prin mijlocirea grefei instantei azi, 9.10.2023.