Data: 28.09.2023
SOLUTIE: Schimbat in parte
RESPINGE apelul civil formulat de reclamantii apelanti Adascalitei Mihaela Ionela, Albu Florica, Anton Felitia, Ardelean Florentin Adrian, Ardelean Ioana Dalia, Ardelean Maria, Ardelean Monica Paula, Ardelean Otilia, Ardelean Sanda Liana, Ardeleanu Florina Mariana, Avram Lavinia Anca, Baican Gyongy, Bala Ioana Bianca, Balint Adriana Mariana, Balint Marie Monica, Balog Ibolya, Baranya Stela Iuliana, Barbaric Florentina Irina, Barcas Carmen, Bele Moza Simona Florica, Benea Gabriela Corina, Bereczki Ibolya, Bereczki Lajos Szilard, Bica Irina Amalia, Bica Mariana, Blaj Florica, Bodog Boghita, Bodrenciu Lidia Maria, Boldog Anett, Bolojan Aurora, Bondici Rodica Adriana, Bontos Felicia, Bortan Veronica Stela, Borza Catita, Borzan Antonele Claudia, Bot Suzana Floare, Botau Daniela, Botoc Ana Loredana, Burca Ana Dorina, Bursuc Georgeta, Buzle Felicia Elena, Buzle Mihaela Liliana, Calugar Adriana Camelia, Ceobanu Elena, Chereches Camelia Adriana, Chichinesdi Florica, Chis Ioana Florentina, Chisvasi Elena Ramona, Chisvasi Gheorghe Mircea, Cimpan Diana Claudia, Cimpan Marioara, Ciorba Ileana, Ciotir Aurica Mirela, Cipleu Liana, Cireap Viorica, Ciuciu Mirabela Ramona, Clitan Andreia Paula, Codilean Mihaela Dorina, Cosma Gratiana Claudia, Costa Mariana, Costea Maricica, Costea Stela Maria, Cozman Nicoleta Sofia, Craciun Dorina Constantina, Craciun Lucia Daniela, Craciunea Liliana Adriana, Cret Maria, Cuc Claudia Luminita, Curta Ioana Elena, Dangeanu Daniela, Deliman Corina Aneta, Doba Flore, Dragan Lucia Daniela, Ellenes Klara Maria, Ellenes Melania Florentina, Erdeli Andra Maria, Erdeli Cosmin Alin, Erdeli Madalina Diana, Farcalau Viorica, Farnas Gabriela, Feher Elena, Fericel Vironica, Filip Lucica, Florian Andrada Diana, Gal Laura Ileana, Gavrilut Mihai Dorel, Gavruta Viorica, Ghent Alina Maria, Gherdan Emilia Timea, Ghiurau Alexandra Cristina, Ghiurau Cristian Florin, Gligor Elena, Gligor Mimi, Goron Cristian Mircea, Groza Florina, Groze Maria, Gubenco Tatiana, Hanga Florentina Claudia, Herea Nicoleta Mariana, Hice Monica, Hirit Alina Corina, Hora Amalia, Hora Simona, Horalipa Elena Viorica, Ianc Sinziana Adriana, Ilincau Cristina Monica, Ivan Ecaterina Mirela, Jakab Victoria Magdalena, Kincses Edit Jolan, Kiss Orsolya Maria, Kocsis Noemi, Lasca Mirela Florica, Lascu Mihaela Nicoleta, Lascu Violeta Florentina, Lazar Alina Patricia, Lazar Georgeta Florica, Lazau Anca, Les Florica Maria, Lucaci Simona, Lucaciu Agkaia Ana, Macicas Ioana, Madiar Valentina, Magda Laura Nicoleta, Man Alina Florica, Manea Florin Aron, Marc Ana Florica, Marcut Mariana Rodica, Margin Anca, Marian Paula, Marinescu Eniko Andrea, Marusca Florita, Mester Cornelia, Micle Zorita Mihaela, Mihalache Lucia Dorina, Mihincau Olivia Elena, Mikloa Iolanda, Milian Camelia Daniela, Miron Anamaria Cristina, Miron Camelia Lorela, Mititean Nicoleta Lidia, Modog Alexandru, Modog Mirela Felicia, Modog Monica Lenuta, Moga Florica, Moldovan Adriana, Moldovan Silvia Mariana, Molnar Monica Elena, Monenciu Maria, Morgovan Marioara, Morvay Szabo Edina Eva, Muller Laura Ioana, Muresan Marioara, Mut Florica Marcela, Neaga Liana, Negrut Adriana Daniela, Negrut Mihaela Ana, Nemeth Noemi, Nica Daniela Luminita, Nichita Adriana Georgeta, Olar Simona Florentina, Omut Simona Daniela, Onaca Dumitru, Oros Dorina Adriana, Oros Marioara Ioana, Oros Olimpia Maria, Oros Rodica, Panc Rodica, Pantea Anca Liana, Pantya Eniko, Parasca Marc Cristina Maria, Parcalab Rodica, Pasca Ioana Mirabela, Pascu Lucia, Paul Lucia, Pernes Florica, Petricas Mariana, Petricau Cristina, Pinter Etelka, Pinzariu Cristian, Pirtea Letitia Gheorghina, Pop Alina, Pop Diana, Pop Ecaterina Tincuta, Pop Elena Mariana, Pop Simona Florina, Popa Thomas Raul, Poplacean Malita Cristina Dalina, Precup Iustina Florica, Puscas Florica, Rat Adriana, Rezmuves Ivan Ramona Flavia, Rob Virgil, Rosu Sergiu Florin, Rotar Mirela, Rotariu Izabela Oana, Saizu Gheorghe Sorin, Secara Mariana Florina, Seghedi Simona, Seica Elena Nicoleta, Silaghi Delia Teodora, Socaciu Florica Adina, Stef Florina Ioana, Stenic Mariana, Susa Dan Sabin, Szakaszlo Eva Andrea, Szilagyi Marta, Tamas Amalia, Tertan Melania Carmen, Tesedan Elena Viorica, Tiburca Laura Elena, Tihoiu Magdalena, Tirnavan Lacrimioara Maria Magdalena, Tonca Angelica Ciorica, Tont Olimpia Cornelia, Toth Alina Lucia, Turcin Marinela, Ungur Mirela Viorica Cecilia, Ungur Olimpia Natalia, Ursu Ancuta Elena, Vancu Madalina Mariana, Veres Andrea, Veres Carmen Florentina, Vese Rodica Corina, Vlad Daniela Simona, Zancu Ecaterina Simona, Zaporojan Iulian, Zot Daniela, in contradictoriu cu intimatii SPITALUL CLINIC JUDETEAN DE URGENTA ORADEA, MINISTERUL SANATATII si DIRECTIA DE SANATATE PUBLICA A JUDETULUI BIHOR, impotriva Sentintei civile nr.2/LM din data de 05 ianuarie 2023 pronuntata de Tribunalul Bihor.
ADMITE ca fondate apelurile civile formulate de apelantul SPITALUL CLINIC JUDETEAN DE URGENTA ORADEA si de apelantul MINISTERUL SANATATII, in contradictoriu cu intimatii Adascalitei Mihaela Ionela, Albu Florica, Anton Felitia, Ardelean Florentin Adrian, Ardelean Ioana Dalia, Ardelean Maria, Ardelean Monica Paula, Ardelean Otilia, Ardelean Sanda Liana, Ardeleanu Florina Mariana, Avram Lavinia Anca, Baican Gyongy, Bala Ioana Bianca, Balint Adriana Mariana, Balint Marie Monica, Balog Ibolya, Baranya Stela Iuliana, Barbaric Florentina Irina, Barcas Carmen, Bele Moza Simona Florica, Benea Gabriela Corina, Bereczki Ibolya, Bereczki Lajos Szilard, Bica Irina Amalia, Bica Mariana, Blaj Florica, Bodog Boghita, Bodrenciu Lidia Maria, Boldog Anett, Bolojan Aurora, Bondici Rodica Adriana, Bontos Felicia, Bortan Veronica Stela, Borza Catita, Borzan Antonele Claudia, Bot Suzana Floare, Botau Daniela, Botoc Ana Loredana, Burca Ana Dorina, Bursuc Georgeta, Buzle Felicia Elena, Buzle Mihaela Liliana, Calugar Adriana Camelia, Ceobanu Elena, Chereches Camelia Adriana, Chichinesdi Florica, Chis Ioana Florentina, Chisvasi Elena Ramona, Chisvasi Gheorghe Mircea, Cimpan Diana Claudia, Cimpan Marioara, Ciorba Ileana, Ciotir Aurica Mirela, Cipleu Liana, Cireap Viorica, Ciuciu Mirabela Ramona, Clitan Andreia Paula, Codilean Mihaela Dorina, Cosma Gratiana Claudia, Costa Mariana, Costea Maricica, Costea Stela Maria, Cozman Nicoleta Sofia, Craciun Dorina Constantina, Craciun Lucia Daniela, Craciunea Liliana Adriana, Cret Maria, Cuc Claudia Luminita, Curta Ioana Elena, Dangeanu Daniela, Deliman Corina Aneta, Doba Flore, Dragan Lucia Daniela, Ellenes Klara Maria, Ellenes Melania Florentina, Erdeli Andra Maria, Erdeli Cosmin Alin, Erdeli Madalina Diana, Farcalau Viorica, Farnas Gabriela, Feher Elena, Fericel Vironica, Filip Lucica, Florian Andrada Diana, Gal Laura Ileana, Gavrilut Mihai Dorel, Gavruta Viorica, Ghent Alina Maria, Gherdan Emilia Timea, Ghiurau Alexandra Cristina, Ghiurau Cristian Florin, Gligor Elena, Gligor Mimi, Goron Cristian Mircea, Groza Florina, Groze Maria, Gubenco Tatiana, Hanga Florentina Claudia, Herea Nicoleta Mariana, Hice Monica, Hirit Alina Corina, Hora Amalia, Hora Simona, Horalipa Elena Viorica, Ianc Sinziana Adriana, Ilincau Cristina Monica, Ivan Ecaterina Mirela, Jakab Victoria Magdalena, Kincses Edit Jolan, Kiss Orsolya Maria, Kocsis Noemi, Lasca Mirela Florica, Lascu Mihaela Nicoleta, Lascu Violeta Florentina, Lazar Alina Patricia, Lazar Georgeta Florica, Lazau Anca, Les Florica Maria, Lucaci Simona, Lucaciu Agkaia Ana, Macicas Ioana, Madiar Valentina, Magda Laura Nicoleta, Man Alina Florica, Manea Florin Aron, Marc Ana Florica, Marcut Mariana Rodica, Margin Anca, Marian Paula, Marinescu Eniko Andrea, Marusca Florita, Mester Cornelia, Micle Zorita Mihaela, Mihalache Lucia Dorina, Mihincau Olivia Elena, Mikloa Iolanda, Milian Camelia Daniela, Miron Anamaria Cristina, Miron Camelia Lorela, Mititean Nicoleta Lidia, Modog Alexandru, Modog Mirela Felicia, Modog Monica Lenuta, Moga Florica, Moldovan Adriana, Moldovan Silvia Mariana, Molnar Monica Elena, Monenciu Maria, Morgovan Marioara, Morvay Szabo Edina Eva, Muller Laura Ioana, Muresan Marioara, Mut Florica Marcela, Neaga Liana, Negrut Adriana Daniela, Negrut Mihaela Ana, Nemeth Noemi, Nica Daniela Luminita, Nichita Adriana Georgeta, Olar Simona Florentina, Omut Simona Daniela, Onaca Dumitru, Oros Dorina Adriana, Oros Marioara Ioana, Oros Olimpia Maria, Oros Rodica, Panc Rodica, Pantea Anca Liana, Pantya Eniko, Parasca Marc Cristina Maria, Parcalab Rodica, Pasca Ioana Mirabela, Pascu Lucia, Paul Lucia, Pernes Florica, Petricas Mariana, Petricau Cristina, Pinter Etelka, Pinzariu Cristian, Pirtea Letitia Gheorghina, Pop Alina, Pop Diana, Pop Ecaterina Tincuta, , Pop Elena Mariana, Pop Simona Florina, Popa Thomas Raul, Poplacean Malita Cristina Dalina, Precup Iustina Florica, Puscas Florica, Rat Adriana, Rezmuves Ivan Ramona Flavia, Rob Virgil, Rosu Sergiu Florin, Rotar Mirela, Rotariu Izabela Oana, Saizu Gheorghe Sorin, Secara Mariana Florina, Seghedi Simona, Seica Elena Nicoleta, Silaghi Delia Teodora, Socaciu Florica Adina, Stef Florina Ioana, Stenic Mariana, Susa Dan Sabin, Szakaszlo Eva Andrea, Szilagyi Marta, Tamas Amalia, Tertan Melania Carmen, Tesedan Elena Viorica, Tiburca Laura Elena, Tihoiu Magdalena, Tirnavan Lacrimioara Maria Magdalena, Tonca Angelica Ciorica, Tont Olimpia Cornelia, Toth Alina Lucia, Turcin Marinela, Ungur Mirela Viorica Cecilia, Ungur Olimpia Natalia, Ursu Ancuta Elena, Vancu Madalina Mariana, Veres Andrea, Veres Carmen Florentina, Vese Rodica Corina, Vlad Daniela Simona, Zancu Ecaterina Simona, Zaporojan Iulian, Zot Daniela si DIRECTIA DE SANATATE PUBLICA A JUDETULUI BIHOR, impotriva Sentintei civile nr.2/LM din data de 05 ianuarie 2023 si a Incheierii din data de 15 februarie 2023 pronuntate de Tribunalul Bihor, pe care le schimba in parte in sensul ca :
Inlatura obligatia paratului Spitalul Clinic Judetean de Urgenta Oradea sa plateasca reclamantilor contravaloarea tichetelor de vacanta aferente anului 2021 in cuantum de 1450 lei.
Obliga paratii la plata catre reclamanti a sumei de 17.700 lei cu titlu de cheltuieli de judecata.
Pastreaza restul dispozitiilor sentintei atacate ce nu sunt contrare prezentei decizii.
Fara cheltuieli de judecata in apel.
D E F I N I T I V A.
Pronuntata in data de 28 septembrie 2023 prin punerea solutiei la dispozitia partilor prin grefa instantei.